THE E-PARLIAMENT
For centuries, philosophers and poets have dreamed of a world parliament
in
which democracy would replace war as a way to determine our future.
Today
for the first time, the Internet offers the opportunity to create
a
democratic, accessible and transparent Earth Parliament – an
E-Parliament.
The E-Parliament will link up the world's more than
20,000
democratically-elected national legislators (who represent today over
60% of
humanity) into a common decision-making body to deal with global
problems.
Policy development, debate and voting will take place online.
The E-Parliament can:
- Enable humanity to act together as one on issues that concern us
all,
through a common assembly made up of our directly-elected
representatives.
- Hold intergovernmental institutions democratically accountable to
the
public, including the United Nations, the World Trade Organization,
the
World Bank and the International Monetary Fund.
- Increase support for UN funding in national parliaments, and create
a
channel for new initiatives to strengthen the UN and solve global
problems.
- Monitor the role of transnational corporations more effectively than
any
national government can.
- Give each citizen a direct and equal voice in global decision-making.
Democratically-elected members of parliament and congress already have
the
mandate to represent their constituents at the highest level. From
their
national legislatures, they already provide the funds for
intergovernmental
organizations, and monitor the work of the national
executive branches that
together make the major decisions in international
organizations. They
already have the power to legislate for the people
of their country. The
E-Parliament represents a natural extension of
their role to deal with the
global challenges of the 21st century.
To give all citizens the chance to participate, the E-Parliament will
be
linked to an E-Forum in which people (including citizens of
non-democratic
countries) can register their views before each parliamentary
vote. The
E-Forum will invite participation from groups, individual
voters and young
people.
WHY IS THE E-PARLIAMENT NEEDED?
Faced with the challenges of the 21st century, our international
system
simply isn't working.
Our current system of global governance includes national
governments,
transnational corporations and unelected international
institutions like the
UN, the World Bank and the World Trade
Organization. This system is proving
unable to respond effectively to
our mounting global problems. The spread
of nuclear weapons,
climate change and the global AIDS epidemic are just
three among many
world-wide problems where the international response is
clearly inadequate to
meet the challenge. Each day 35,000 children die for
lack of food and
simple vaccines, while each day our governments spend
another $2 billion on
preparations for war. The failure to meet global
needs and solve global
problems threatens our children and our planet.
Some of the problems with our present international system are:
• The decision-making process is too slow. To deal with a problem
like
climate change we must await agreement among more than 100
national
governments, each one fiercely defending its short-term national
interests.
As a result, the problems move faster than the negotiations.
• There is no adequate source of funds to meet urgent global
needs.
National governments show no sign of providing resources on the scale
needed
to end extreme poverty or to protect the global environment.
• The United Nations is too weak. When close to a million Rwandans
were
being murdered in cold blood, the UN failed to act. National
governments
were unwilling to send their own troops to protect the people of
Rwanda, and
the UN has no rapid deployment force of its own.
• There is a steady erosion of democracy as decision-making moves to
the
global level. More and more decisions are shifting from
national
governments, many of them democratically elected, to corporations
and
international institutions that are not.
Indeed, some of those institutions are very far from democratic. In
the
World Bank and IMF, the richest 20% of humanity controls a majority of
the
votes, and the poorest 20% has just a tiny fraction of the voting
power. In
the UN General Assembly, the Seychelles has the same voting
power as India,
Iceland the same as the United States. A single
national dictator wields
the same vote as a government elected by millions of
people. Nowhere at the
global level is there an influential
decision-making body made up of
democratically-elected representatives.
Few people would choose such a
system for their national or local governance,
and many people would
hesitate to strengthen institutions at the global level
that suffer from
such a profound democratic deficit.
The E-Parliament can help to solve these problems. Rather than
awaiting
consensus among more than 100 governments, it can adopt proposals in
the
same way any parliament does: by a vote among the people's
elected
representatives. By engaging legislators directly in global
issues, and
enabling them to better oversee the expenditure of funds at the
global
level, it can increase support in national parliaments for funding
global
needs. The E-Parliament can be a channel for launching proposals
to create
new ways to raise funds for global priorities, and to build a more
effective
United Nations. And it can bring democracy to the global
level.
Beyond these goals, the E-Parliament can help achieve a deeper
objective.
If people know that when they vote in national elections they are
choosing
representatives not only for their national parliament but also for
a common
parliamentary body at the global level, it can strengthen the sense
of
global responsibility among both voters and representatives. If in
that
body every individual is equally represented regardless of their
nationality
or ideology, race or religion, wealth or poverty, it can
strengthen their
sense of being not only citizens of their nation, but
citizens of the
planet.
HOW WILL THE E-PARLIAMENT WORK?
WEBSITE: A virtual „Parliament Building" will be created in a
style
resembling other parliament buildings. Like other parliaments, as
you move
from room to room you will pass „statues," picturing heroes of the
global
struggle for democracy – from Demosthenes of ancient Athens to Aung
San Su
Kyi of today's Burma, from Abraham Lincoln and William Wilberforce
who
helped to end slavery, to Mahatma Gandhi, Martin Luther King, Jr. and
Nelson
Mandela. The building will house not only the E-Parliament, but
the E-Forum
where ordinary citizens and citizen groups can register their
views. The
web address will be www.e-parl.net, since the first syllable of the
word
meaning „parliament" is common to many languages.
MEMBERSHIP: Every member of a national or regional legislature who has
been
elected in fair, open and democratic elections will be
automatically
entitled to be a member of the E-Parliament. More than
60% of humanity
already has the right to vote in free, multi-candidate
elections. As soon
as China and other closed societies begin to hold
open elections, the
members of their parliaments will be entitled to
join. A committee of the
E-Parliament will be responsible for
monitoring elections and determining
that they are free and fair.
STRUCTURE: The E-Parliament will function like any national parliament
or
congress, with a system of committees to monitor major
international
institutions, to oversee the budget, and to cover major global
issues such
as environment, war prevention, human rights, poverty
eradication, etc.
VOTING: Each legislator can vote on the E-Parliament website by
entering a
PIN number. To ensure that every citizen is equally
represented, the vote
of each member will be weighted according to a simple
formula. The
weighting will be determined by dividing the population of
the country by
the number of elected members of parliament. In the
European Union, the
total number of legislators in each country will include
their members of
both the national parliament and the European
Parliament. Citizens can go
to the website and see how their
representatives have voted.
DECISIONS: The E-Parliament, like many parliaments, can make decisions
in
three ways: through non-binding resolutions, through budgets, and
through
proposed legislation which requires action by national parliaments
for its
implementation. In the latter case, legislation will only bind
a country
once the national parliament has ratified it, and in some cases
only when a
set minimum number of countries have ratified. In this way,
no nation can
be forced into an action it considers unacceptable.
MONITORING: The E-Parliament can establish committees to oversee not
only
intergovernmental institutions, but national compliance with existing
UN
conventions, such as the Biodiversity Convention or the Convention on
the
Rights of the Child. It can also monitor the role of
transnational
corporations, and propose steps toward a safe framework of
rules for
international economic competition, in which the environment and
human
rights are protected. Monitoring committees can issue reports to
all
members of parliament.
FUNDS: Funds from the E-Parliament's budget will be devoted to
global
public goods, including meeting the needs of the poorest
citizens,
preventing armed conflict, protecting the global environment and
promoting
democracy and human rights. In all these areas, our current
international
system has failed to generate funding on the scale
needed. Funds for the
budget may be provided by national parliaments,
from individuals or from
agreed common revenue sources. Common revenue
sources might include a levy
approved by national parliaments on carbon
emissions or currency transfers.
Some parliaments may allow taxpayers, if
they wish, to devote perhaps 1% of
their taxes to the E-Parliament.
HOW WILL THE E-FORUM WORK?
THE ROLE OF CITIZEN MOVEMENTS: Civil society will play a crucial role
in
the E-Parliament, both in encouraging legislators to take part, and
in
developing proposals and initiatives for consideration by the
E-Parliament.
If legislators hear from their constituents that the voters
want to be
represented on critical global issues as well as national issues,
they will
participate in the E-Parliament in increasing numbers. The
E-Forum will
help to ensure maximum public participation in the
E-Parliament's work from
the start.
REGISTERING YOUR OPINION: Before decisions are brought to the
E-Parliament,
citizens and citizen groups will have an opportunity to express
their views
through the E-Forum. This may take the form of voting in
different
categories. The categories might include: citizen groups
recognized by the
United Nations, with each group's vote listed for all to
see; voting by
people of voting age; and voting by young people under 18
years old.
Individuals could register to vote, just as they would for
national
elections. A report of how the vote broke down country by
country would be
sent to all parliamentarians before the vote in the
E-Parliament.
CITIZENS UNDER AUTHORITARIAN REGIMES: Citizens of countries ruled
by
dictatorships would also have the right to vote in the E-Forum. They
would
thus be able to express their views to members of the E-Parliament,
even if
they cannot do so to their own leaders.
SENDING MESSAGES TO YOUR REPRESENTATIVES: The E-Forum will provide an
easy
way for people to send messages to their representatives. By
typing in
their postcode or the name of their representative, they will get a
blank
email message window, in which they can write a letter and send it with
one
click.
DEVELOPING POLICY PROPOSALS: The E-Forum can also provide discussion
and
drafting rooms where representatives of global civil society can
prepare
initiatives and proposals for submission to the E-Parliament.
IS THERE PUBLIC SUPPORT FOR THIS?
Opinion polls show strong public support for more democracy at the
global
level. For example, in October 2000 EarthAction commissioned a
nationwide
opinion poll in the United States by the respected pollster
Yankelovich
Partners. One of the questions asked related to
democratizing international
relations. The question, and the public's
response, were as follows:
An increasing number of important decisions are made in
international
institutions such as the United Nations, the World Bank or the
World Trade
Organization. The people making the decisions are either
representatives of
national governments or employees of the international
organizations. There
have been proposals for a People's Assembly at the
United Nations, directly
elected by the world's citizens, to hold those
international organizations
democratically accountable to the public.
Would you favor or oppose the
creation of such a UN People's Assembly?
a. Favor 57%
b. Oppose 30%
c. Don't
know 13%
Even in the nation that owes more to the UN in unpaid dues than any
other,
there is majority support for a democratic assembly at the global
level.
HOW CAN THE E-PARLIAMENT HELP TO SOLVE SPECIFIC GLOBAL PROBLEMS?
By its very nature, the E-Parliament helps to reduce the democratic
deficit
in global decision-making. To understand how it can help to
solve other
global problems, let us take three examples.
CHILDREN'S RIGHTS: Almost all the world's governments have signed the
UN
Convention on the Rights of the Child. By doing so, they have
promised
among other things to prevent the use of child soldiers, to care
for
children without families, and to provide universal primary
education.
These commitments are widely disregarded: there are 100 million
homeless
children living on the streets of the world, millions more with no
chance to
go to school, and hundreds of thousands of child soldiers.
It is already the role of legislators to monitor the work of
national
governments. Who better than a committee of the E-Parliament
to monitor
compliance by national governments with their commitments under
the
Convention? The parliamentarians could issue regular reports,
highlighting
cases where governments are showing blatant disregard for their
treaty
commitments. Members of the relevant national parliaments can
then help to
draw attention to the reports, and press for changes in policies
and
budgetary priorities.
If the E-Parliament can develop a substantial budget of its own, meeting
the
needs of the poorest children would undoubtedly be one of the
highest
priorities for its funds.
CLIMATE CHANGE: While increasing floods, hurricanes and droughts claim
ever
more victims, the intergovernmental negotiations on climate change
are
moving painfully slowly – if they are moving at all.
Members of the E-Parliament, working together with civil society
groups,
could develop a concrete proposal for a „global deal" setting a safe
global
limit to greenhouse gas emissions, equitably shared among the
world's
nations. A far-reaching solution to the climate threat is much
more likely
to receive majority support in the E-Parliament, than to achieve
„consensus"
among all governments in the intergovernmental
negotiations. If approved by
the E-Parliament as a piece of proposed
legislation, it could then be
introduced into national parliaments for
implementation there. The
parliamentarians voting on ratification at
the national level will have
already been involved in shaping the agreement
internationally, and
therefore may be more likely to support it. A
committee of the E-Parliament
would monitor compliance by countries that have
ratified.
Of course, triggering a serious world-wide response to global
warming
through the parliamentary channel is still not easy, given the
vested
interests blocking the way. But it is entirely possible that
action can be
generated more quickly in this way than through the tried – and
so far
failed – approach of negotiations between government executive
branches.
STRENGTHENING THE UN: National executive branches tend to be opposed to
a
stronger United Nations, because they see it as a competitor for
influence.
The E-Parliament could be an excellent launching-pad for specific
proposals
to reform and strengthen the UN. Indeed, if the UN fails to
act, the
members of the E-Parliament have in principle the democratic
mandate, and
the resources, to create new international agencies directly
accountable to
them.
PROMOTING DEMOCRACY: More than 60% of humanity now enjoy basic
democratic
freedoms, though their democracies may be far from perfect.
Almost all of
Europe and Latin America, North America, much of sub-Saharan
Africa and
large parts of Asia have won the right to vote in open
elections. But some
2 billion people, including 1.3 billion Chinese,
are still denied the rights
that others take for granted. In the
countries still ruled by
dictatorships, brave individuals are risking their
lives and their freedom
to demand democracy.
Who better than the elected representatives of the democratic world,
coming
from every continent and across the political spectrum, to give
strong
support to those advocates of democracy? National parliaments
could
contribute funding to the E-Parliament for this purpose, thus making
clear
that the funding is not intended to advance the interests of any
foreign
power. With both moral and financial support, the E-Parliament
could
strengthen the hands of those who have the courage to speak out for
the
right to vote in countries where the government's power rests on
fear. This
is a task far better carried out by the E-Parliament than by
the UN, where
dictators wield the vote and the veto, or by individual Western
countries.
On these and many other issues, the E-Parliament could improve the
prospects
for solving global problems.
WHAT ARE THE ADVANTAGES OF THIS APPROACH TO DEMOCRATIC GLOBAL GOVERNANCE?
EASY AND SIMPLE: The very simplicity of the idea – to link up
existing
national legislators into a global body – is one of its
strengths. The
E-Parliament can start small, keep growing, and it's
hard to stop. Because
the E-Parliament can be established by a group – the
elected representatives
of the people – who gain influence as a result of its
creation, it is likely
to win considerable support.
HARD TO CORRUPT OR TAKE OVER: Because of the large number
of
representatives involved – more than 20,000 – the E-Parliament will be
much
more difficult to corrupt than smaller national parliaments.
Back-room
deals will be hard to hatch. A legislature on this scale
wasn't possible
until the last year or two; with the Internet, it is quite
possible. At the
same time, the requirement for national ratification
of proposed legislation
provides an important safeguard against abuse of the
E-Parliament's
influence, or the „tyranny of the majority." All
deliberations and voting
will be available for all to see on the Internet,
making it fully
transparent.
IMMEDIATELY HELPS BRING GLOBALIZATION UNDER DEMOCRATIC CONTROL: One of
the
key problems with globalization has been the lack of
accountability. Now
there can be a global institution accountable to
the people and easily
accessible to civil society. It is an institution
where the global South
will be fairly represented, unlike the World Bank or
the IMF.
E-PARLIAMENT TIMELINE
STAGE 1: PREPARE
- Raise funds
- Create Organizing Committee of legislators, with Expert Group of
advisors,
to develop structure, rules of procedure, website design, etc.
- Create high-level council of supporters, with celebrities,
former
political leaders, etc.
- Create and begin to implement strategy for media coverage, polling
public
support and mobilizing support from civil society.
- Launch informal working groups on initiatives to bring to
the
E-Parliament, e.g. on revision of UN Charter, children's rights,
global
climate change, finance for global needs, promotion of democracy,
AIDS.
- Create initial website and database of legislators.
STAGE II: LAUNCH
- Media launch.
- Major recruitment drive for participation by legislators, using
meetings,
speaking tours, peer recruiting, media, Internet and encouragement
from
civil society groups.
- First round of votes on structure and rules of procedure, then election
of
Speaker, committee membership, etc.
- Continue informal working groups to develop new initiatives.
STAGE III: E-PARLIAMENT AT WORK
- Members debate and vote on first resolutions.
- Oversight committees on UN, WTO, World Bank etc. begin work.
- Seek funds from parliaments, and from new and innovative sources,
for
E-Parliament to appropriate towards global public goods.
- Work to double number of participating legislators every year for first
5
years, and work to create channels whereby decisions in the E-Parliament
can
be brought to national legislatures for consideration.
- Work to build participation of civil society groups and the public in
the
E-Folrum, including citizens from non-democratic countries.
AN UNPRECEDENTED OPPORTUNITY
Two recent developments combine to create a new opportunity to build a
more
democratic, just and secure world. The first is the growing power
of
international citizen movements, which we have seen in the movement to
ban
landmines and the creation of an International Criminal Court, among
other
examples. The second is the transformation being wrought by the
Internet.
Using the Internet, we can take democracy to the global level.
With
democracy, the opportunities for world civil society to reshape the
global
agenda will be dramatically increased. The creation of the
E-Parliament can
improve humanity's prospects for a better future. But
as our global
problems mount, time is not on our side. We must approach
the task with
real urgency. We would be very grateful for your help in
this endeavour.
For more information, contact:
Lois Barber, Executive Director, EarthAction, Amherst, USA.
Email:
amherst@earthaction.org
Nicholas Dunlop, Executive Director, EarthAction, Wye, United
Kingdom.
Email: nick@earthaction.org.uk
Sirpa Pietikäinen, Member of Parliament, Finland; Chair,
Executive
Committee, World Federation of United Nations Associations.
Email:
sirpa.pietikainen@eduskunta.fi
William Ury, author and Director, Harvard Project on Preventing War.
Email:
wury@law.harvard.edu